Taffy Mail Review


Taffy Mail offer a service to deliver a box of American candy to your door on a monthly subscription basis.

They sent me the Classic selection, which retails for £14.99 per month.

Taffy Mail
The full contents of the Classic box.

Taffy Mail

It’s a colourful, mixed box of goodies. There’s a good choice of chewy sweets, chocolate treats, fizzy sour things and crisps.

Taffy Mail

I’m not a chocolate / Oreo fan, but everyone else was (there was six of us sampling the box) and the creme filled Oreo Brownie went down a treat. Even more popular was the Almond Joy, which was like a Bounty, but with an almond on top. Yum.

taffy-04

Everyone described the Whoppers Milkshake as being like soft, strawberry flavoured maltesers. They were bursting with flavour and deliciously creamy.

Taffy Mail

The Sweet & Sour Skittles were a mix of super-fruit & bitter flavours, and contained a particularly mouth watering watermelon flavour (the green one). A great find! The kids loved the Pop Rocks which was like nitro-powered Space Dust. Extremely noisy! We weren’t too sure about the Grape Fanta, being a full sugar juice with a potent flavour.

My favourite treat in the box was the incredible Herr’s Deep Dish Pizza Flavoured Cheese Curls. I have *never* had crisps which so accurately replicated the flavour they were aiming for. Incredibly, it just felt like you’d eaten a bit of pizza. This Willy Wonka-esque piece of mastery was mind-blowing!

Taffy Mail

The chewy sweets were all pleasant enough. The Sweetarts had a mouth-watering Cherry Punch flavour but the Chewy Banana tasted quite artificial. The Mini Burgers and Cow Tales were loved by the wee ones. The Bit-O-Honey is an extremely chewy, rich tasting sweet – watch your fillings!

It’s not the healthy choice, obviously. It’s a box of sweets. What did you expect? It is a novelty buy, being able to buy things that you wouldn’t ordinarily get in your supermarket. American fruit flavoured sweets with a seem to have much more of a zing about them compared to UK alternatives. The discovery of the Herr’s Pizza Cheese Curls were worth the cost of the box alone!

This choice would be £14.99 including postage. That’s a little over £1 an item to your door, which I think is great value for imported goodies. There are alternative subscription options of a Lite box with 4-5 items (£7.49 per month) or an Extra box which has up to 20 sweets, a can of Soda and one premium item (£24.99 per month).

Taffy Mail is a lot of fun. We all had our own favourites and the novelty of the unknown was a good conversation point. I recommend it!

Disclaimer : Taffy Mail sent me this box for review purposes. Yes, we brushed our teeth straight after!

182 Comments

  1. Helen Blackmore
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies look amazing!

  2. Natalie White
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    I absolutely love fanta grape. It’s ridiculously yummy!

  3. Karl Borowy
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    almond joy

  4. iain maciver
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    oreo brownies

  5. Julie C
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    whoppers!

  6. Michaela Smith
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy 🙂

  7. sharon martin
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Strawberry Whoppers Milkshake

  8. Nicola Dow
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    would love to try Woppers Strawberry milkshake x

  9. Natasha Whenham
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The sweet and sour skittles, yum!

  10. Bev
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Pizza curls!

  11. Julie T
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers Strawberry Milkshakes

  12. melanie stirling
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Whoppers.

  13. Tracy Hanley
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers Milkshake look delish

  14. Harline parkin
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers!

  15. Kevin Honey
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  16. Jo Hutchinson
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    fanta grape

  17. Lynsey Buchanan
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownie

  18. Sally Sam
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Sweet Tarts Ropes, They look soooo good!

  19. Lindsey Stuart
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    I would love the sour skittles oh yummy! I love the sourness 🙂

  20. Andrew Petrie
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Skittles. It’s been such a long long time.

  21. Claire Simpson
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies

  22. gemma brown
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    that almond joy

  23. don erwood
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy for me

  24. Andy Wedge
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Skittles for me please

  25. ValB
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy 🙂

  26. Kim Neville
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  27. Louise Brown
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies sound very tempting!

  28. deborah smith
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    the almond joy sounds yumm !! brilliant giveaway thankyou x

  29. JODIE BEAUMONT
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    the oreo brownies!

  30. Leila Benhamida
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers sounds great

  31. Jacqueline Fawcett
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies, yum! 🙂

  32. Laura Harris
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Never tried Fanta grape, and would be fab now it’s on the heavy tax list…

  33. Rachel Craig
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy. I am fond of almonds and chocolate.

  34. Simone lee
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies sound awesome yummy

  35. Carole
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Skittles

  36. Honey McKinley
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Whoppers sound the most unusual so would like to try those

  37. Holly Gibson
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The almond joy looks really nice!

  38. Lisa Rowsell
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Skittles

  39. Simon tutthill
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Fanta grape looks great.

  40. Claire Nutman
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Skittles

  41. Paul Wilson
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    I’d like to try Almond Joy.

  42. clair downham
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    the skittles for me please

  43. Sparklett21
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy❤️

  44. S Bufton
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Almond Joy

  45. 17 March 2016
    Reply

    It all looks yummy but grape fanta is a must try.

  46. Simon C
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    I think the Pop Rocks.

  47. Kim M
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Would like to try the Whoppers

  48. Annabel Greaves
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies please xx

  49. Lisa Parker
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    almond joy

  50. Marianne Daniels
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    sweet tart ropes

  51. Vivien Baird
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy,

  52. Angela McDonald
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Herr’s Deep Dish Pizza Flavoured Cheese Curls sound amazing!

  53. anne murray
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Has to be Skittles for me.

  54. stephen ashdown
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    Pop Rocks, I just love space dust when I can find it!!

  55. Bob Clark
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    almond joy

  56. Fiona Paley
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Oreo Brownie would be my first choice.

  57. Rey Chunara
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Fanta grape sounds good

  58. Paul von der Fecht
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    The Skittles.

  59. jamie millard
    17 March 2016
    Reply

    oreo brownie

  60. Natalie Gillham
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    I would most love to try the Almond Joy

  61. Graham Ross
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    almond joy

  62. Sarah Lambert
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies very yummy 🙂

  63. Helen Stratton
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    The Deep Dish Pizza Cheese Curls sound delicious!

  64. helen tovell
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    The Whoppers Milkshake is the one I would most like to try

  65. Rich Tyler
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo Brownie

  66. Jayne Kelsall
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    The Grape Fanta, never knew it existed but would love to try it 🙂

  67. Kate Knight
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    the oreos are my fav!

  68. Phil O'neill
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo Browney

  69. charlotte clavier
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Grape Fanta

  70. Joanne Tovey
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Strawberry Milkshake Whoppers!!

  71. amy fidler
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    oreo brownies

  72. 18 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers Milkshake sound good

  73. Gemma Massey
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies

  74. Rachel Arnup
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Grape Fanta

  75. colin Anderson
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers

  76. Dadmac
    18 March 2016
    Reply

    Skittles

  77. 18 March 2016
    Reply

    I grew up in the States and Bit o Honey is one of my fav and haven’t had any in over 20 years

  78. Ruth Harwood
    19 March 2016
    Reply

    the pop rocks xx

  79. Rebekah Jones
    19 March 2016
    Reply

    I would love to try the Almond Joy !!

  80. Alica
    19 March 2016
    Reply

    The Oreo Brownies!!

  81. lisa sargent
    19 March 2016
    Reply

    Skittles please 🙂 Thanks

  82. Monica Gilbert
    20 March 2016
    Reply

    I want to try the Skittles. I’ve never seen that flavor. I need to use this post to make a list of items to buy when I next visit my family.

  83. Jade
    20 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  84. 20 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers strawberry milkshake sweets.

  85. Victoria Thurgood
    21 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies

  86. Andrew Robeson
    21 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo cream-filled brownies!

  87. CLAIRE RICHARDSON
    23 March 2016
    Reply

    The skittles,i’m like a kid when it comes to skittles, love them.

  88. Hester McQueen
    23 March 2016
    Reply

    Malted milk balls

  89. Debby
    23 March 2016
    Reply

    The Cherry Punch Sweetarts appeal to me and I know my better half would love the chocolate and cheesy goodies, especially the Whoppers Milkshake 🙂

  90. Marie Evans
    23 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies i have just discovered Oreo biscuits & i love them.lol

  91. Sara Dunn
    23 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers

  92. April
    24 March 2016
    Reply

    Oero brownie!!!!

  93. Iris W
    26 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy looks lovely

  94. Susan B
    26 March 2016
    Reply

    The Sweetarts Ropes look the yummiest to me.

  95. Gillian Brewster
    27 March 2016
    Reply

    Love to try almond joy the most. Absolutely love the taste of almonds so I’m hoping this would be some dreamy ‘candy’ x

  96. Ruth Robinson
    27 March 2016
    Reply

    The Herr’s Deep Dish Pizza Flavoured Cheese Curls sound delicious!!

  97. 27 March 2016
    Reply

    I would love Strewberry milkshake whoppers

  98. MANDY DOHERTY
    27 March 2016
    Reply

    The Cow Tales x

  99. karen wells
    27 March 2016
    Reply

    I’d love to try the Pop Rocks

  100. Sarah-Jane
    28 March 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  101. michelle o'neill
    28 March 2016
    Reply

    would love to try almond joy

  102. Cheryl Price
    29 March 2016
    Reply

    I would love to try the Almond Joy, that sounds delicious

  103. 29 March 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers Strawberry Milkshake

  104. Jo Hutchinson
    30 March 2016
    Reply

    The Pizza curls

  105. 30 March 2016
    Reply

    Oreo Brownies! Yum!

  106. Rachel Butterworth
    30 March 2016
    Reply

    The Strawberry Milkshake Whoopers.

  107. Kirsty Cannon
    30 March 2016
    Reply

    After reading your description it without a doubt has to be the pizza curls. Pizza heaven!

  108. Teresa Lee
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    The Deep Dish Pizza Flavoured Cheese Curls

  109. 1 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  110. Antonio Santos
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  111. Helen A
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    The Herrs deep dish pizza cheese curls, they sound yum!

  112. Steph
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    The grape Fanta, sounds good

  113. lucy oliphant
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    skittles 🙂

  114. Hollie
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy sounds amazing! To be honest though, they all do and I’d love to try them all!

  115. Laura Harrison
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies, very yummy xx

  116. Lisa Wilkinson
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    The Skittles

  117. Spencer Wright
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  118. Wendy Smith
    1 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  119. SUNITA VERMA
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    grape fanta

  120. Lynne OConnor
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    The Whoppers look interesting

  121. Kerry Webber
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  122. Vickie Jackson
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    The strawberry whoppers sound divine! I’m a real sucker for grape Fanta so that would be gone in a flash!

  123. A.E. ADKINS
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Fanta – gotta love grape flavour!

  124. stephen smith
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    whoppers!

  125. Andrew Hindley
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    whoppers!

  126. Georgina Sudron
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Strawberry milkshake whoppers sound tasty ????

  127. Patricia Parkinson
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Skittles

  128. 2 April 2016
    Reply

    I would love to try the skittles

  129. Alison MacDonald
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    The Almond Joy 🙂

  130. Serena La Pietra
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Those Banana chewy things.

  131. Robert Price
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  132. sallyann Johnston
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    The grape Fanta x

  133. Caitlin
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond joy

  134. Emma Walton
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    I would like to try the Almond Joy – Thank you for the opportunity to win this fantastic prize! Good luck everybody.

  135. Andrew Seaman
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    whoppers! They look great x

  136. tina edwards
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    fanta grape

  137. Stevie
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Those burgers. typical Americans.

  138. Karen Smith
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Oreo Brownie

  139. Andrew Zazulak
    2 April 2016
    Reply
  140. paul jackson
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    the whoppers

  141. Angela Young
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers Strawberry Milshakes look divine.

  142. Angela Macdonald
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    the Almond Joy, looks yummy!

  143. jackie curran
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    I would like to try the oreo brownie

  144. 2 April 2016
    Reply

    oreo brownie 😀

  145. Kirsti Peters
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    I have tried them all which is why I would love to win…I am homesick and miss Almond Joy the most

  146. Clare Parker
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    The Almond Joy xx

  147. Amanda Brett
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    Grape soda-absolutely DELICIOUS! Thank you for the chance to enter x

  148. Jacqueline Roberts
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    The strawberry whoppers

  149. 2 April 2016
    Reply

    Blue Razz Pop Rocks

  150. Emma Perry
    2 April 2016
    Reply

    the sweet and sour skittles…..I love anything sour 🙂

  151. Caroline Wright
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Yummmmmmmy ☺

  152. John Myers
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Those Pizza Curls look so tasty

  153. Karl Foxley
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers for me 🙂

  154. 3 April 2016
    Reply

    Grape Fanta

  155. Becky Cornes
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    I would love to try the mini burgers please. They look delicious and would create a taste explosion

  156. Lisa Lewis
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    oreo brownies

  157. zina tye
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    ohhh almond joy sounds great!

  158. kim tanner-hill
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    You have made the pizza curls sound soo yummy, really want to try those!

  159. Sarah Lewis
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  160. Judith Luscombe
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond joy

  161. Joanna Sawka
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownie

  162. sarah pavlidis
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers Milkshake

  163. Mandy Burden
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond joy sounds really tempting .. Thanks for the great giveaway !

  164. Andrea A
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  165. Zareen Choudhury
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Has to be the Pop rocks!!! 😀

  166. Julie Booth
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    almond joy

  167. tammi nutting
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    oreo brownies .yum

  168. Katie Hodges
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    I’d love to try the Grape Fanta!

  169. lisa
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Oh my 3 kids and i want to try the whoppers lol

  170. LAURA MARIE NESBITT
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Oreo brownies ???? X

  171. Miriam Krutska
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond joy because I looooove almonds

  172. Kirsty Woods
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Whoppers sound fab

  173. Eggtizz
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Skittles!!!!

  174. Dawn Chapman
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    almond joy

  175. Deborah Mackenzie
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  176. Nisa Soruklu
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Whoppersssss

  177. 3 April 2016
    Reply

    The Fanta Grape please 🙂 X x

  178. Tina L-D
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    Almond Joy

  179. nicola james
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    whoppers nomnom

  180. Joanna Kasznicki
    3 April 2016
    Reply

    the pizza crisps. I want to see if they are as good as you say

  181. Gillian Brewster
    3 July 2016
    Reply

    Quite reasonably priced option. I’m a big fan of American ‘candy’ this is a new company for me so will take a look, looks a great range of products to.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.